Yeah i have to agree, the two speed is the best bet if it is in the price range. there are times when it helps to put more pressure on the fish and you can change gears immediately to get the result you need. if the one speed is all the pocketbook can make possible then pick both up and spin them to see which feels better to you. because at that point it is like comparing apple and oranges. both work great and have their finer points. it is just with saltwater fishing you never know what your going to pull up. they will both work fine and your gonna love either one you end up choosing. the only other thing i thought about while writing is that when you are fishing from the pier there is alot of space between you and the water and being able to get the fish over the rail faster may be more desireable, in that case the 6:1 would be the best bet for you. like i said though, you gonna love either one, and you pleanty of time to get more avets in the future and secure your place as an avet ho later.